showSidebars ==
showTitleBreadcrumbs == 1
node.field_disable_title_breadcrumbs.value ==

Pre-Conference Talk by LIAW Shao Yi | The Hidden Cost of Transparency: How Evaluator Stance Shapes Feedback Responses among Individual Platform Participants

Please click here if you are unable to view this page.

 


The Hidden Cost of Transparency: How Evaluator Stance Shapes Feedback Responses among Individual Platform Participants

About the Talk

Platforms increasingly reveal who evaluated a contribution and with what stance, but little is known about how this transparency shapes recipients, who often decide for themselves whether to act on feedback. We distinguish feedback content from the evaluative signal and examine how an evaluator's revealed stance shapes recipients' responses to feedback using two field studies. The first, on an online healthcare platform, finds that evaluative stance matters: physicians improve service performance after receiving positive patient reviews, whereas negative reviews produce no significant improvement. The second isolates the effect of evaluator stance on a crowdsourcing platform where voting shifted from anonymous to attributable while substantive feedback remained unchanged. Once evaluators’ stances become visible, ideators become less likely to incorporate suggestions from detractors, while incorporation of suggestions from supporters, non-voters, and ideators themselves remains unaffected. These findings show that negative evaluative signals can weaken receptiveness to substantive feedback, highlighting an important hidden cost of platform transparency.

This is a Pre-Conference talk for 2026 Pre-ICIS SIGDSA Symposium (SIGDSA 2026).

About the speaker

LIAW Shao Yi is a Ph.D. candidate in Information Systems, supervised by Prof. TANG Qian. Her general research interests are in product and human innovation with an emphasis on how individuals generate, evaluate, and refine ideas on digital platforms.